The Gap Check · Thesis & Method

What we believe the Gap predicts, and how we're testing it.

The Gap Check is new. Established engagement surveys have decades of data behind them; we don't yet. So here is exactly what we measure, how it's scored, what we expect it to predict, and how we'll prove or disprove that in the open.

The thesis

A smaller Gap predicts better execution of the plan.

For thirty years, engagement research has tied how people experience work to five business outcomes: productivity, profitability, customer satisfaction, retention and safety. Gallup's Q12 meta-analysis, now covering 183,806 work units, is the best-known evidence. Scott Kimball's doctoral dissertation tested the Q12 against the performance numbers of 108 organizations.

Our thesis: the distance between the company leaders intend and the company people experience predicts how well the plan gets executed, and through execution, the same outcomes engagement predicts.Engagement surveys ask how people feel. The Gap Check adds two things they don't measure: whether your leaders agree with each other, and whether their picture of the company matches what people actually report. That is why we start with plan attainment, an outcome engagement research rarely tracks.
Seven hypotheses

What we expect each part of the Gap to predict.

Each hypothesis names the part of the Gap Check we expect to matter most and the number a company already tracks. These are the hypotheses we are testing, not findings.

OutcomeWe expect it to trackMeasured by
H1Plan attainmentSmaller Alignment and Deployment GapsShare of the year's top priorities met or on track
H2ProductivityHigher Structure scores and a smaller Deployment GapRevenue per employee
H3ProfitabilityA smaller overall Performance GapEBITDA or operating margin
H4Customer outcomesHigher Direction scoresNPS or CSAT
H5RetentionHigher Stability scoresVoluntary turnover, annualized
H6Safety & qualityHigher Structure scoresRecordable incidents, or errors and rework
H7Integration resultsA smaller Gap between pre-merger companiesPlan attainment during an acquisition or merger

Why these links: Structure is about who decides and how work moves, so it should show up first in output and error rates. Stability is about trust and a sustainable pace, so it should show up in who stays. Direction is about belief in where the company is going, so it should show up in how customers are treated.

How it's scored

Every number in your report, explained.

25 statements, three gatesEight statements each for Structure, Stability and Direction, plus one overall item, all on a 1–5 scale. 4 or 5 counts as agreeing; 1 or 2 as disagreeing. Two open questions capture people's own words.
Gate scoresEach gate's average answer is converted to a 0–100 index, alongside the share of people who agree and disagree.
Alignment Gap (leaders vs. leaders)Before the survey, each leader forecasts how people will answer. The spread between leaders' forecasts is your Alignment Gap: under 8 points is tight, 8–15 moderate, over 15 wide.
Deployment Gap (leaders vs. people)The distance between the leaders' average forecast and what people report. Under 5 points is small, 5–15 moderate, 15 or more large.
Performance Gap (people vs. the ideal state)How far each gate sits from 80% agreeing with no more than 10% disagreeing. That ideal state is the Scalewrights standard: a deliberately high bar, not a statistically derived cutoff.
The overall checkWith 10 or more responses, we correlate each person's gate average with their overall rating. A strong correlation says the gates explain most of how people feel; a weak one says something else is at work, and the report tells you so.

Priorities follow the gate order: Structure first, then Stability, then Direction. Fixing direction before structure rarely holds.

Anonymity & data

Built so no one can be singled out.

No names, no emailsThe survey never asks who someone is. Leaders see combined results only.
Groups of five or moreAny department or group with fewer than five responses is folded into the company totals. Groups are never combined to reveal a smaller one. Up to eight departments, so each stays large enough.
Comments without contextWritten comments are shown in random order with no team attached.
Outcome numbers stay privateThe optional outcome scorecard never appears in your reports or to your team. It is used for research only if you opt in, and only anonymized and combined with other companies. Your company is never named.
An honest comparison

Where established engagement surveys are ahead, and where the Gap Check is different.

What they have that we don't yet

  • Decades of published research linking scores to outcomes
  • Large national norms to compare against
  • Independent, peer-reviewed reliability and validity studies

What the Gap Check adds

  • The leadership forecast: whether leaders know what their people experience
  • Leader-to-leader alignment, measured in points
  • A diagnosis tied to executing the plan, with a 90-day pathway
  • Five days, fully automated, from $1,500

If you need a decades-old, normed engagement index, buy one. If you need to know whether your plan is surviving the trip from the leadership team to the front line, that is what the Gap Check is built for.

How we'll test it

The proof design, published before the data.

We're stating the test now, before results come in, so no one can say we moved the goalposts.

Collect outcomes alongside the Gap. Every buyer can add six numbers they already track: plan attainment, revenue and headcount, margin, a customer score, voluntary turnover and safety or quality. Optional, private and opt-in for research.
Test at a point in time. Do companies and departments with a smaller Gap report better outcomes in the same period?
Test change over time. At the six-month retest, the same numbers are collected again. Do companies that closed more of their Gap improve more?
Check the instrument itself. Internal consistency of each gate, whether the 24 statements group into three gates as designed, and test-retest stability.
Reach a real sample. About 200 departments, roughly 50 companies, to reliably detect a modest relationship (a correlation near 0.2).
Publish what we find. Including any hypothesis the data does not support.
What we say today“Our thesis is that the Gap predicts how well a company executes its plan. We're testing it, and here is how.”
What we won't sayThat the Gap Check is proven, or that closing your Gap guarantees a specific improvement. Not until the data says so.
Who built it

Research roots, operator experience.

PhD in Industrial/Organizational Psychology, Loma Linda University
Doctoral internship at Gallup under Don Clifton, contributing to the research behind CliftonStrengths
Dissertation tested the Q12 against the performance numbers of 108 organizations
Helped scale and exit Capstone Nutrition, then Chief People Officer of INW

Questions about the method, or interested in research collaboration? Email scott@scalewrights.com.

Sources: Gallup, Q12 Meta-Analysis, 2024. Kimball, L. S., doctoral dissertation, Loma Linda University, 2004.

Find your gap · from $1,500