The Gap Check is new. Established engagement surveys have decades of data behind them; we don't yet. So here is exactly what we measure, how it's scored, what we expect it to predict, and how we'll prove or disprove that in the open.
For thirty years, engagement research has tied how people experience work to five business outcomes: productivity, profitability, customer satisfaction, retention and safety. Gallup's Q12 meta-analysis, now covering 183,806 work units, is the best-known evidence. Scott Kimball's doctoral dissertation tested the Q12 against the performance numbers of 108 organizations.
Each hypothesis names the part of the Gap Check we expect to matter most and the number a company already tracks. These are the hypotheses we are testing, not findings.
| Outcome | We expect it to track | Measured by | |
|---|---|---|---|
| H1 | Plan attainment | Smaller Alignment and Deployment Gaps | Share of the year's top priorities met or on track |
| H2 | Productivity | Higher Structure scores and a smaller Deployment Gap | Revenue per employee |
| H3 | Profitability | A smaller overall Performance Gap | EBITDA or operating margin |
| H4 | Customer outcomes | Higher Direction scores | NPS or CSAT |
| H5 | Retention | Higher Stability scores | Voluntary turnover, annualized |
| H6 | Safety & quality | Higher Structure scores | Recordable incidents, or errors and rework |
| H7 | Integration results | A smaller Gap between pre-merger companies | Plan attainment during an acquisition or merger |
Why these links: Structure is about who decides and how work moves, so it should show up first in output and error rates. Stability is about trust and a sustainable pace, so it should show up in who stays. Direction is about belief in where the company is going, so it should show up in how customers are treated.
Priorities follow the gate order: Structure first, then Stability, then Direction. Fixing direction before structure rarely holds.
If you need a decades-old, normed engagement index, buy one. If you need to know whether your plan is surviving the trip from the leadership team to the front line, that is what the Gap Check is built for.
We're stating the test now, before results come in, so no one can say we moved the goalposts.
Questions about the method, or interested in research collaboration? Email scott@scalewrights.com.
Sources: Gallup, Q12 Meta-Analysis, 2024. Kimball, L. S., doctoral dissertation, Loma Linda University, 2004.